Say "sat nav software" to people and they'll probably mention TomTom. There is, however, other software out there that promises to do the same sort of job. Here's a new one that I've never really seen before. It's called Garmin Mobile XT and I've spent the past week using it in real-life situations to see whether it's up to the mark.
It arrives in a blue DVD case with a quick-start guide. I promptly ignored this and opened the box containing the microSD card. From experience I've always figured that if you can't at least start using software without a manual, it ain't worth looking at. The microSD card comes with a miniSD and SD adaptor so it'll slot into any Windows Mobile phone and install itself. The data is held on a 512Mb card which, for those that own larger cards, is a bit annoying. When I asked Garmin whether it was possible to copy the date to a larger capacity card I was told "no". They state...
"Due to proprietary and security reasons, it is not possible to transfer your Garmin Mobile XT data to a larger card."
I tried several different ways around this but, despite trying to install, then copy the data, or copying the data first - neither method seemed to work unfortunately :(
First lets take a look around what's in the box and what you
may need to get things running. The Garmin Mobile XT does, of course, require a
GPS receiver. You might be lucky enough to have a built-in GPS, however you can
always get yourself a Bluetooth GPS to talk to the satellites up in space.
Here's a look at the contents and a brief introduction, by way of video.
Apologies in advance for calling the handset the "MDA Vario" in this
vid, it's actually the
T-Mobile MDA Compact III..doah! :)
I am, like many people, a pretty frequent TomTom user. So it's
with no surprise that I'll probably be comparing this software to TomTom. First
up, the install is pretty quick and easy. I did have to uninstall some of my
other software first though, as the Garmin Mobile XT software wanted to install
about 6Mb of data on the phones memory. I didn't see a way to alter the
installation path either, but it installed fine after that and started up.
Here's the first screen you'll see. It's a fairly simple affair
- always key when you're about to start a journey. You've got the GPS signal
strength, a help function (shown right) and then two huge "pokeable"
buttons to get you moving quickly. There's a few ways to get you where you want
to be, so let's show you.
This is the first screen - you can navigate to a variety of places,
intersections and locations
Let's start with the type of navigation most people will want to
use - address based navigation. Getting to a postcode or address is probably one
of the most used functions of sat-nav software. I'm going to click on
"Addresses" from the option above. This brings me to the screen below...
Ah - that's a little disappointing - especially when you
consider that this is the GB and Ireland version of the software. Why should I
need to enter the name of the country ? Can't I just hop into the postcode entry
? Sometimes, as shown above, it'll remember that you've previously chosen
England, but a lot of the time it won't. Even worse, if I start typing in
"England" it'll come up with countries like "Estonia".. countries that aren't
included on this GB / Ireland version of the software.
After entering the country (grrrr) I'm met with another option -
I can either search by city or spell the city / enter the postcode.
Below we'll go through both options so you can see what happens
depending on what you press. There's benefits to being able to search all cities
or within cities, especially when you've only got part of an address or you've
been given an address quickly over the phone.
Search all cities
Spell City/Postal Code
Let's imagine someone said,
"go to 1 Long Lane" and you know
it's in Clayton, but you don't have
any other info.
Either enter a city / town name like this..
..or bang in a postcode like this..
Got it! You even have part of the postcode
now too.
..then enter a house number..
Done!
This is all well and good, but you may not always need to get to addresses.
Sometimes you may want to find a hotel or a bank in the local area. Instead of
choosing "Addresses" from the main screen we'll instead choose "Food / Hotels".
It's a little misleading as there's lots of other categories, including
Shopping, Entertainment and Fuel to name just a few. Here's the full list..
It'll list stuff near to your location, so if I choose "Bank /
ATM" (Cash Machines) I'll get a nice list of banks in my local area - great if
you're short on cash..
I decided to do a quick video showing how this section can help
you out when you're in a tight spot. I noticed here that, now and again, the GPS
data seems to take longer than it should to be displayed.
What started to become clear here is that the setup and navigation settings
are really flexible, but when I got going - when I started off on my journey to
the petrol station - things started to go a little strange. The first thing I
noticed is that there was a noticeable delay between GPS data being received and
it appearing on the screen. An example came when I entered a round-about. The
lovely Garmin Mobile XT voice stated, "in 200 metres enter the round-about".
Ah... I already had. When I left the roundabout the voice stated "take second
exit".. but, I already had. When driving I noticed that the scrolling 3D display
seemed to get "stuck", which I really couldn't understand. There wasn't anything
blocking the line-of-sight from the unit to the satellites, so it seemed a
little weird.
Let's look again at those navigation options. On the first page we've covered
navigating to "Addresses" and "Food, Hotels". You can also navigate to addresses
in your Contacts list or My Locations. These are shown below. You can manage
your locations through the settings option..
You also get to navigate to recent finds - excellent for those
places you forgot to save into your "My Locations" bit. There's also the ability
to search intersections. For British readers, that's roads and junctions. If you
want to be totally hardcore you can enter the coordinates.
Once you've chosen where you want to go, there's a map and the
chance to get the weather conditions - plus you can download the traffic
information too. This is good if you've got quite a distance to cover and want
to see what the weather is like at your destination.
Once you start your drive you're met with a 3D representation of
the road and a nice lady telling you what to do. You can change this if you
wish.
Your speed and heading is shown, plus you can access further
screens - like the driving / trip time shown above - simply by hitting the soft
keys. The 3D view will dim depending on the time, which is a nice touch. These
are the day colours but it'll swap to dark blue colours in the evening. It's not
just the 3D map view either - all the navigation menus will swap to darker
colours so you won't get blinded when you're trying to navigate in the dark.
During your journey the map - as default - tends to zoom out
when you're on a road that doesn't involve any changes in navigation for some
time. This happens especially on motoways where you've got to drive long
distances without deviation, and I found that it zoomed out to such a degree
that you could actually see the next turn. On a 20 mile trip up the M6 this
seemed a little strange to me, and it meant that I couldn't see up-coming
junctions where I could, if I wanted, turn off if I wanted fuel or to divert
slightly. Again, I'm comparing this to TomTom which zooms out just a little way
but still shows you what roads are going past - even if you're on a fast
motorway.
But then the problem was fixed. How? Well, the screen went off. For some
reason, the Windows Mobile power saving options seem to kick in when you're on a
long bit of road with no change in direction for some time. This is fixable by
adjusting your power saving settings, but when you're merrily bombing up the
motorway you may not glance at the device and there's a chance you can miss your
turn-off.
In the settings option you can change pretty much everything about the
program ...
If I click on the "Map" setting above I can turn off that pesky
auto-zoom feature.
Within the Routing settings you can alter what vehicle you're
in. It's set as Car / Motorcycle as default but there's navigation for vehicles
like trucks (which I haven't tested, but I presume it'll avoid low bridges and
small roads) and even bicycle or on foot! You can also tweak whether you'd like
to get the fastest or the shortest route, plus you can alter what you'd like to
avoid. For me I'll be putting a tick in the "Toll Roads" option. The M6 Toll is
right around the corner from here and the toll booths will happily dive into my
wallet and grab nearly £5 for travelling as little as a three miles up it.
It's set to avoid traffic as default, however you can turn it
off if you don't mind getting stuck in jams! Plus, if you're in some huge 4x4
you can choose to drive over unpaved roads.
There's also loads of tools to play with. This is where you can
manage your locations, contacts and tracks logs. Yes, track logs. Tucked away
here is a neat little feature where you can record your trips. More on this
shortly.
The Tools menu also reveals the "Where Am I?" option, which is always useful if
you're ... completely lost, plus there's the ability to simulate routes and
check the map.
Here's those track recording options alongside the data
management options I mentioned earlier. Here's your chance to save your trip on
your phone storage and then stick it on your PC later. Good for proving to your
boss where you've been I guess :)
Conclusion
Garmin Mobile XT is a good bit of kit, don't get me wrong. The
range of options and the navigation details are great. Little tweaks like the
track logs, auto dimming screen and the ability to quickly find petrol stations,
hotels and cash machines in your local area are all fab. However, I was a little
disappointed with some of the default settings of the program - that auto-zoom
does my head in and I couldn't seem to shake off the GPS lag at times. It could
that I need to adjust the baud rate on my settings, but this program sets the
GPS up automatically when it can, so I'm hoping it didn't get things wrong.
There's also those few niggles with the country selection but, for just over £50
with free traffic updates, you've got to work this all into the equation.
No, it's not as good as TomTom, but it is cheaper and - for the money - Garmin Mobile XT isn't too bad.